In
Janice Radway's 1983 study, she set out to answer the age old question: why do
so many women read romance novels and are there specific novels they are more
likely to enjoy? With the help of friends, Radway was led to bookstore employee
and romance novel expert Dot Evans. Evans is an expert on romance novels and
every day she helps another woman find the perfect romance to enjoy. Dot's regular
customers vary in their demographic data, with women of various ages,
education, work history, income, marital status, parental status, and even
church attendance. When a sample of Dot's customers and Dot herself were asked
their primary reason as to why they read romance novels, a majority of the
women overwhelmingly say that these books are an "escape" and they
help them relax. But, the answer to the age old question can't be that simple,
can it?
In
some way, yeah, it kind of is. These romance novels draw women away from their
present surroundings that may sometimes be too much to bear. But can't TV do
the same thing? According to the women Radway interviewed/surveyed, many of the
women favored reading books instead because books are viewed as socially better
and educational, and the women say they feel less guilty reading a book for 5
hours as opposed to watching TV for 5 hours. Dot says that romance novels help
women escape from their everyday and allow the a break from the running kids to
school, cleaning the house, cooking, and general catering to others. Reading
books is time for women to relax and have a small amount of time to themselves,
something these women desperately need. It should also be noted that some women
read romance novels for the emotional relationships and a longing some women
have to have one of these perfect fantasy relationships, but this reason should
not overpower the other positive reasons women read romance.
Dot's
customers know and understand that the plot of romance novels is far-fetched
and imaginative, and the women say that the exaggerated romance makes it even
easier to indulge and get lost in. Essentially, the farther the plot is from the
women's everyday life, the more likely they are to read and like it. Dot's customers
say that the reading of romance novels provides hope, pleasure, and contentment
in their stressful day to day lives. When Radway asked Dot's customers what their
favorite romance novels were, Radway found that nearly all the books the women
listed followed a similar narrative structure, revolved around a single couple
made up of a beautiful and sexually innocent woman and a strong handsome man
capable of empathy and loving gestures.
It
should be important to note what kind of romance novels that Dot and her
customer's don't enjoy. They don't enjoy books where the heroine of the book
gets abused by men or her hero and especially don't like the books where the
heroine gets abused by men and falls in love with the abuser in the end. Dot
and her customer's are also not fond of sexually explicit books that have
"perversions" or "promiscuity." These women do not like
books that have the male hero having relations with many women; they are firm
believers in the idea of one man and one woman. A good romance novel, according to Dot and her
customers, revolves around a positive relationship between the hero and
heroine, a bright woman and a masculine man that isn't afraid to be emotional,
and a gradually developing love between the hero and heroine.
So,
why do women read romance? It seems that the simplest and most accurate answer
really is that they provide an escape from everyday reality for women who lead
a busy and not so relaxing life.
No comments:
Post a Comment